- 2004 - 2002: Jim Schauer , Larry Lasha , Keith McNew
- 2002 - 1997: Jim Schauer , Joe Rall, Keith McNew
- 1996: Myron Smith, Joe Rall, Donna Murphy
- 1996: Myron Smith, Joe Rall, Thomas Doyle
- 1994 - 1993: Thomas Doyle, Myron Smith, Charles McCall
- 1992 - 1989: Jim Griffin, Bud Chess, Charles McCall
- 1988 - 1987: Dennis Jones, Wes Carhart, Charles McCall
- 1986 - 1985: Gale Decker, Wes Carhart, Dennis Jones
- 1984 - 1983: Gale Decker, John Vrtis, Roy Canterbury
- 1982 - 1981: Roy Canterbury, John Vrtis, John Buglewicz
- 1980 - 1979: Roy Canterbury, Ray Shoop, Jon Buglewicz
- 1978 - 1977: Jim Milam, Ray Shoop, Roy Canterbury
- 1976 - 1975: Jim Milam, George Kimmick, Roy Canterbury
- 1974 - 1973: Carl Meyers, George Kimmick, Roy Canterbury
- 1972 - 1971: Charlie McDaniel, Denzel Goodwin, Alex Beltramo Jr.
- 1970 - 1967: John Camerlo, Denzel Goodwin, Charlie Mcdaniel
- 1966 - 1965: Charlie McDaniel, Denzel Goodwin, Alex Beltramo Jr.
- 1964 - 1963: Finis Parks, Charlie McDaniel, Alex Beltramo Jr.
- 1962 - 1961: John Camerlo, Finis Parks, Charlie McDaniel
- 1960 - 1957: Finis Parks, Norman Boyd, John Camerlo
- 1956 - 1955: Finis Parks, Norman Boyd, Frank Orecchio
- 1954 - 1949: Finis Parks, Norman Boyd, J. Walter Martin
- 1948 - 1947: Ralph Callaghan, Finis Parks, J. Walter Martin
- 1946 - 1943: Frank Zavislan, Finis Parks, Ralph Callaghan
- 1942 - 1939: W.R. Griffiths, Finnis Parks, Frank Zavislan
- 1938 - 1937: W.R. Griffiths, Finis Parks, Thomas Cavanaugh
- 1936 - 1935: Charles Sell, Finis Parks, Thomas Cavanaugh
- 1934 - 1933: John Bald, Finis Parks, Charles Sell
- 1932 - 1929: John Bald, D.N. Cooper, William H. Smith
- 1928 - 1927: John Bald, C.A. Somerville, Frank Stienmier
- 1926 - 1923: S.G. Kelso, C.A. Somervile, Frank Stienmier
- 1922 - 1921: G.V. Hodgin, C.S. Somervile, Frank Stienmier
- 1920 - 1917: G.V. Hodgin, James Belknap, J.V. McCandless
- 1916 - 1915: W.A. Chapson, W.H. Pigg, J.V. McCandless
- 1914 - 1913: W.H. Pigg, W.R. Allred, W.A. Chapson
- 1912 - 1911: S.G. Kelso, W.H. Lagrange, W.R. Allred
- 1910 - 1909: W.H. Lagrange, S.G. Kelso, W.R. Allred
- 1908 - 1907: S.G. Kelso, W.H. Lagrange, Albert Phillips
- 1906 - 1905: S.G. Kelso, W.H. Lagrange, Albert Philips
- 1904 - 1903: H.L. While, S.G. Kelso, Albert Phillips
- 1902: Albert Phillips, H.L. White, Julius McCandless
- 1901: Don Crampton, H.L. White, Julius McCandless
- 1900: Don Crampton, H.L. White, Julius McCandless
- 1899: Albert Phillips, H.L. White, Julius McCandless
- 1898: Albert Phillips, H.L. White, Julius McCandless
- 1897: J.H. Harrison, Albert Phillips, Julius McCandless
- 1896: Edwin Lobach, J.H. Harrison, Albert Phillips
- 1895: Edwin Lobach, J.H. Harrison, A.W. Alexander
- 1894: F.H. Bengley, Edwin Lobach, A.W. Alexander
- 1893: F.H. Gengley, A.L. Green, A.W. Alexander
- 1892: F.H. Gengley, A.L. Green, A.W. Alexander
- 1891: Samual Bond, A.L. Green, A.W. Alexander
- 1890: Samual Bond, J.C. Palmer, A.W. Alexander
- 1889: Samual Bond, H.W. Hodges, J.C. Palmer
- 1887: John C. Palmer
- 1886: S.T. Ferrier, H.W. Hodges, J.C. McKillip
- 1885: Imam C. McKillip
- 1884: H.W. Hodges
- 1882: J.J. Phelps, A.F. Alexander, Louis Muelbach
- 1881: J.J. Phelps, Edwin Lobach, A.F. Alexander
- 1881 - 1879: Edwin Lobach
- 1881 - 1877: W.H. Thompson, Allen Alexander
- 1879 - 1877: Allen Alexander
- 1880 - 1876: John H. Harrison
- 1876: Adam J. Hager
- 1876 - 1873: William Shepherd
- 1875 - 1872: Stephen J. Tanner
- 1874 - 1871: William J. Schoolfield
- 1872 - 1869: Jacob J. Risser
- 1873 - 1870, 1867: Augustus Sartor
- 1869 - 1866: John Locke
- 1871 - 1868, 1865: John V. Callen
- 1864: David Roop, John Locke, Jesse Frazier
- 1863: Daniel Virden, J.A. Toof, Jesse Frazier
- 1862: Lewis Conley, B.F. Allen, Franklin Bruce